Toledo vs West Virginia Volleyball: Toledo Wins 3-2 (Sep 11)

Final · 5 setsFri, Sep 11, 2026

3:2

Toledo won at West Virginia 3-2 (20-25, 25-21, 25-14, 20-25, 15-11) on Fri, Sep 11, 2026. Toledo's Sophie Catalano led with 20 kills, and Janelle Green added 19 digs.

Data through Nov 3, 1:50 PM CT · final Sep 11

Set	1	2	3	4	5	Sets
TOLEDO	20	25	25	20	15	3
WVU	25	21	14	25	11	2

Win probability

West Virginia above 50 · Toledo below

Biggest swing: 11.5% to Toledo — set 5, TOLEDO 8-6 WVU. Kill by Ava Siefke (set by Grace Freiberger). WVU win probability 39% → 28%.

Pre-match

Season fit · includes this match

TOLEDO 51.9%48.1% WVU

Toledo wins

3-0

13.3%

3-1

19.5%

3-2

19.0%

West Virginia wins

3-0

11.7%

3-1

18.0%

3-2

18.4%

TOLEDO break %: 41.0% vs this opp
WVU break %: 40.7% vs this opp

Exact Markov model on each team's RallyIQ serve and receive strength, adjusted for schedule and applied to this matchup (D1 average break % 42.5%). Ratings use the whole season, including this match. Gold = actual result.

Top plays

Largest win-probability swings

01
Ava SiefkeKill+11.5%
Kill by Ava Siefke (set by Grace Freiberger)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 8-6 WVU · TOLEDO 61% → 72%
02
Kayla OzanichKill+10.2%
Kill by Kayla Ozanich (set by Madelyn Bach)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 9-6 WVU · TOLEDO 72% → 82%
03
West VirginiaAce+9.9%
West Virginia ace
Set 5 · TOLEDO 4-4 WVU · WVU 38% → 48%
04
Jessica CostlowKill+9.6%
Kill by Jessica Costlow (set by Janelle Green)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 3-2 WVU · TOLEDO 49% → 59%
05
Jessica CostlowKill+9.5%
Kill by Jessica Costlow (set by Meg Jarrett)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 4-2 WVU · TOLEDO 59% → 68%
06
Nina HorningKill+9.3%
Kill by Nina Horning (set by Alexis Finnvold)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 1-2 WVU · WVU 48% → 57%
07
Sophie CatalanoKill+8.9%
Kill by Sophie Catalano (set by Janelle Green)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 1-0 WVU · TOLEDO 49% → 58%
08
Sophie CatalanoKill+8.3%
Kill by Sophie Catalano (set by Janelle Green)
Set 5 · TOLEDO 14-11 WVU · TOLEDO 87% → 96%

Box score

Official NCAA box

Toledoaway

Player	S	K	E	TA	Hit%	AST	SA	SE	DIG	RE	BS	BA	BLK	PTS
10Kayla OzanichMB	5	13	0	19	.684	1	1	0	1	0	1	2	2	16
6Jessica CostlowOH	5	9	2	33	.212	0	2	2	11	2	0	0	0	11
22Sierra PertzbornMB	5	7	1	10	.600	0	0	0	4	0	1	3	2.5	9.5
9Audrey DyasMB	5	4	4	16	.000	0	1	0	1	0	1	2	2	7
15Madelyn BachS	5	0	0	0	–	19	0	0	9	0	0	0	0	0
7Avery AdamskiL/DS	3	0	1	1	-1.000	0	1	1	5	0	0	0	0	1
16Sophie CatalanoOPP	5	20	2	41	.439	0	0	0	2	0	0	0	0	20
14Ava SiefkeOH	5	13	6	37	.189	0	0	0	6	0	0	1	0.5	13.5
1Grace FreibergerL/DS	5	0	0	0	–	5	2	5	13	4	0	0	0	2
3Janelle GreenS	5	1	0	2	.500	37	0	2	19	0	0	0	0	1
21Meg JarrettL/DS	4	0	0	0	–	1	1	3	5	0	0	0	0	1
23Lilly MerkMB	1	0	0	1	.000	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
Team totals		67	16	160	.319	63	8	13	76	7	3	8	7	105

West Virginiahome

Player	S	K	E	TA	Hit%	AST	SA	SE	DIG	RE	BS	BA	BLK	PTS
13Nina HorningOH	5	19	6	55	.236	0	3	4	11	2	0	0	0	22
18Trinity SheridanOPP	5	17	3	34	.412	0	0	0	1	0	0	2	1	18
22Maddy McGathMB	5	5	3	16	.125	1	1	2	0	0	0	1	0.5	6.5
5Alexis FinnvoldS	5	1	0	5	.200	39	0	2	6	0	0	0	0	1
7Mirjam Karoliine KaskMB	3	1	1	4	.000	0	0	0	4	0	0	1	0.5	1.5
20Macie SmithOH	2	2	3	14	-.071	0	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	2
23Cassidy BrunsL/DS	5	0	0	0	–	0	1	1	5	1	0	0	0	1
19Reagan TurkL/DS	5	0	0	0	–	4	0	0	17	2	0	0	0	0
2Anna BarrOH	4	6	2	15	.267	0	0	0	2	0	0	2	1	7
6Saar BertelsOH	4	6	1	17	.294	0	0	0	2	0	0	1	0.5	6.5
0Lauren DuncanS	4	1	0	2	.500	11	2	0	3	0	0	0	0	3
4Eily PainterL/DS	4	0	0	0	–	1	0	0	10	2	0	0	0	0
8Camille HuffMB	3	2	1	4	.250	0	0	0	0	0	2	3	3.5	5.5
16Lucie SmardovaL/DS	1	0	0	0	–	0	0	0	2	1	0	0	0	0
Team totals		60	20	166	.241	56	7	9	64	8	2	10	7	96

Starters listed first. BLK is the NCAA total: a solo counts 1, a block assist ½. Recaps and press releases usually quote solos + assists instead, so the same night can be reported as a bigger, whole number. The box score is the source for every counting stat on this page.

Momentum

Point differential by rally

Longest run 5 TOLEDO · WVU 5

Set 1

20-25

Longest run 2 TOLEDOWVU 5

Set 2

25-21

Longest run 4 TOLEDOWVU 3

Set 3

25-14

Longest run 5 TOLEDOWVU 2

Set 4

20-25

Longest run 5 TOLEDOWVU 5

Set 5

15-11

Longest run 3 TOLEDOWVU 2

Bars above the line = West Virginia leads, below = Toledo leads. Bright bars are points inside a run of 3+.

Rotations

Sideout and break % by rotation slot

Toledo

Slot	Sideout %	Break %
1	72%13/18	50%11/22
2	63%12/19	41%9/22
3	71%10/14	41%7/17
4	53%9/17	40%6/15
5	69%9/13	47%8/17
6	53%8/15	25%3/12
All	64%61/96	42%44/105

West Virginia

Slot	Sideout %	Break %
1	65%13/20	29%4/14
2	50%11/22	40%8/20
3	67%10/15	21%3/14
4	60%9/15	44%8/18
5	53%9/17	31%4/13
6	56%9/16	47%8/17
All	58%61/105	36%35/96

Slot = rotations since the start of the set (slot 1 is the lineup a team opened the set in), not a fixed player alignment. Only clean sets count (5 of 5 here): sets where the NCAA play-by-play has gaps or score corrections are left out because the rotation can't be tracked through them.

Rally log

201 rallies

#	TOLEDO-WVU	Srv	Point	End	Player	Setter / blockers / passer	WP Δ
Set 1
1	1-0	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+1.8
2	1-1	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+1.8
3	2-1	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn	set Madelyn Bach	+1.8
4	3-1	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Blocked	Macie Smith	blk Sierra Pertzborn, Audrey Dyas	+2.6
5	3-2	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+1.7
6	4-2	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Madelyn Bach	+1.8
7	5-2	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+2.5
8	5-3	TOLEDO	WVU×5	Serve err	Toledo		+1.6
9	5-4	WVU	WVU×5	Attack err	Ava Siefke		+2.6
10	5-5	WVU	WVU×5	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.8
11	5-6	WVU	WVU×5	Kill	Macie Smith	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.9
12	5-7	WVU	WVU×5	Attack err	Audrey Dyas		+2.9
13	6-7	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Janelle Green	+1.9
14	7-7	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Attack err	Maddy McGath		+3.0
15	7-8	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Macie Smith	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.1
16	8-8	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Janelle Green	+2.1
17	8-9	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Kill	Maddy McGath	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.2
18	8-10	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+3.1
19	8-11	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+3.0
20	9-11	WVU	TOLEDO	Attack err	Mirjam Karoliine Kask		+1.8
21	9-12	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.1
22	9-13	WVU	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.8
23	10-13	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+1.6
24	11-13	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Ace	Toledo	aced Lucie Smardova	+2.8
25	11-14	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Mirjam Karoliine Kask	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.3
26	12-14	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Madelyn Bach	+2.0
27	12-15	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+2.3
28	13-15	WVU	TOLEDO	Blocked	Macie Smith	blk Sierra Pertzborn, Audrey Dyas	+2.0
29	14-15	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+3.5
30	14-16	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.7
31	15-16	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+2.5
32	16-16	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Attack err	Maddy McGath		+4.1
33	16-17	TOLEDO	WVU	Attack err	Avery Adamski		+3.1
34	17-17	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Audrey Dyas	set Janelle Green	+3.0
35	17-18	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+3.3
36	17-19	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Alexis Finnvold	set Eily Painter	+4.6
37	17-20	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Maddy McGath	+4.1
38	18-20	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+2.1
39	19-20	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Mirjam Karoliine Kask	+4.2
40	19-21	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+3.7
41	20-21	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Madelyn Bach	+3.1
42	20-22	TOLEDO	WVU×4	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+4.1
43	20-23	WVU	WVU×4	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Jessica Costlow	+4.6
44	20-24	WVU	WVU×4	Ace	West Virginia	aced Grace Freiberger	+2.5
45	20-25	WVU	WVU×4	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+0.7
Set 2
1	0-1	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.8
2	1-1	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+1.8
3	2-1	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Ace	Toledo	aced Reagan Turk	+2.7
4	2-2	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.8
5	2-3	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.8
6	2-4	WVU	WVU×3	Attack err	Jessica Costlow		+2.8
7	3-4	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+1.8
8	4-4	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Ace	Toledo	aced Nina Horning	+2.8
9	4-5	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.0
10	5-5	WVU	TOLEDO×4	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Janelle Green	+2.0
11	6-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×4	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Madelyn Bach	+2.9
12	7-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×4	Blocked	Macie Smith	blk Sierra Pertzborn	+2.9
13	8-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×4	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+2.8
14	8-6	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.8
15	9-6	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Madelyn Bach	+2.0
16	10-6	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Attack err	Nina Horning		+2.6
17	10-7	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.5
18	10-8	WVU	WVU	Ace	West Virginia	aced Grace Freiberger	+2.6
19	11-8	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn	set Madelyn Bach	+2.1
20	12-8	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Ace	Toledo	aced Eily Painter	+2.7
21	12-9	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+1.6
22	13-9	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+1.9
23	14-9	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Janelle Green	+2.3
24	14-10	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+1.2
25	15-10	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Janelle Green	set Grace Freiberger	+1.6
26	15-11	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+1.2
27	16-11	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+1.6
28	16-12	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Saar Bertels	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.2
29	17-12	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+1.6
30	17-13	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Saar Bertels	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.1
31	18-13	WVU	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn	set Madelyn Bach	+1.5
32	19-13	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Ace	Toledo	aced Eily Painter	+1.5
33	20-13	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Attack err	Anna Barr		+0.9
34	20-14	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Serve err	Toledo		+0.3
35	20-15	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Lauren Duncan	+0.8
36	20-16	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Anna Barr	set Lauren Duncan	+1.3
37	21-16	WVU	TOLEDO	Blocked	Anna Barr	blk Ava Siefke, Kayla Ozanich	+1.4
38	21-17	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Lauren Duncan	+0.8
39	22-17	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+1.3
40	23-17	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Blocked	Nina Horning	blk Audrey Dyas	+0.9
41	23-18	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Blocked	Ava Siefke	blk Trinity Sheridan, Mirjam Karoliine Kask	+0.2
42	23-19	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Saar Bertels	set Alexis Finnvold	+0.6
43	23-20	WVU	WVU×3	Attack err	Ava Siefke		+1.3
44	24-20	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+1.7
45	24-21	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Saar Bertels	set Alexis Finnvold	+0.5
46	25-21	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+1.2
Set 3
1	1-0	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Janelle Green	+2.4
2	2-0	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Audrey Dyas	set Janelle Green	+3.4
3	2-1	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.3
4	3-1	WVU	TOLEDO×3	Serve err	West Virginia		+2.4
5	4-1	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+3.3
6	5-1	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Attack err	Trinity Sheridan		+3.1
7	5-2	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+1.9
8	6-2	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Janelle Green	+2.2
9	6-3	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.9
10	7-3	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+2.2
11	7-4	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Maddy McGath	set Alexis Finnvold	+1.9
12	8-4	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+2.2
13	8-5	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.0
14	9-5	WVU	TOLEDO×5	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Grace Freiberger	+2.3
15	10-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Attack err	Nina Horning		+2.9
16	11-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Kill	Audrey Dyas	set Janelle Green	+2.4
17	12-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Attack err	Nina Horning		+1.8
18	13-5	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Attack err	Nina Horning		+1.3
19	13-6	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+0.6
20	14-6	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Janelle Green	+0.9
21	14-7	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Camille Huff	set Alexis Finnvold	+0.6
22	14-8	WVU	WVU	Blocked	Sophie Catalano	blk Saar Bertels, Camille Huff	+1.2
23	15-8	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+1.2
24	16-8	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Janelle Green	+1.2
25	16-9	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+0.5
26	17-9	WVU	TOLEDO	Bad set	Alexis Finnvold		+0.7
27	17-10	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Maddy McGath	set Meg Jarrett	+0.4
28	18-10	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+0.7
29	18-11	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Saar Bertels	set Alexis Finnvold	+0.4
30	19-11	WVU	TOLEDO×3	Attack err	Maddy McGath		+0.6
31	20-11	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn	set Madelyn Bach	+0.4
32	21-11	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Ace	Toledo	aced Reagan Turk	+0.2
33	21-12	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Maddy McGath	set Lauren Duncan	·
34	22-12	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Grace Freiberger	+0.1
35	23-12	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	·
36	23-13	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Anna Barr	set Lauren Duncan	·
37	24-13	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Janelle Green	·
38	24-14	TOLEDO	WVU	Blocked	Audrey Dyas	blk Camille Huff	·
39	25-14	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Audrey Dyas	set Janelle Green	·
Set 4
1	1-0	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Attack err	Saar Bertels		+3.4
2	2-0	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Ace	Toledo	aced Nina Horning	+3.3
3	2-1	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+2.2
4	3-1	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Anna Barr	+2.4
5	3-2	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Reagan Turk	+2.3
6	4-2	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Janelle Green	+2.4
7	5-2	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Blocked	Nina Horning	blk Sierra Pertzborn, Kayla Ozanich	+3.3
8	5-3	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+2.1
9	5-4	WVU	WVU×3	Ace	West Virginia	aced Grace Freiberger	+3.4
10	5-5	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Lauren Duncan	set Reagan Turk	+3.7
11	6-5	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn	set Madelyn Bach	+2.6
12	6-6	TOLEDO	WVU×5	Kill	Maddy McGath	set Lauren Duncan	+2.6
13	6-7	WVU	WVU×5	Ace	West Virginia	aced Grace Freiberger	+3.9
14	6-8	WVU	WVU×5	Ace	West Virginia	aced Jessica Costlow	+3.9
15	6-9	WVU	WVU×5	Blocked	Ava Siefke	blk Trinity Sheridan, Maddy McGath	+3.7
16	6-10	WVU	WVU×5	Ace	West Virginia	aced Jessica Costlow	+3.4
17	7-10	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+2.0
18	8-10	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Kayla Ozanich	+3.5
19	8-11	TOLEDO	WVU	Attack err	Audrey Dyas		+2.7
20	8-12	WVU	WVU	Blocked	Audrey Dyas	blk Camille Huff	+3.5
21	9-12	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+2.1
22	9-13	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Camille Huff	set Lauren Duncan	+2.5
23	10-13	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+2.1
24	10-14	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+2.5
25	10-15	WVU	WVU	Blocked	Jessica Costlow	blk Anna Barr, Camille Huff	+3.0
26	11-15	WVU	TOLEDO×5	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+1.6
27	12-15	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Janelle Green	+3.0
28	13-15	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+3.8
29	14-15	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Blocked	Camille Huff	blk Kayla Ozanich	+4.5
30	15-15	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×5	Ace	Toledo	aced Cassidy Bruns	+5.1
31	15-16	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+3.8
32	16-16	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+3.7
33	17-16	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn		+5.8
34	17-17	TOLEDO	WVU×3	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+3.9
35	17-18	WVU	WVU×3	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Lauren Duncan	+6.2
36	17-19	WVU	WVU×3	Attack err	Sierra Pertzborn		+6.1
37	18-19	WVU	TOLEDO	Attack err	Trinity Sheridan		+3.7
38	18-20	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Lauren Duncan	+4.5
39	19-20	WVU	TOLEDO	Serve err	West Virginia		+3.8
40	19-21	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Saar Bertels	set Reagan Turk	+4.9
41	20-21	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Madelyn Bach	+4.0
42	20-22	TOLEDO	WVU×4	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Lauren Duncan	+5.4
43	20-23	WVU	WVU×4	Kill	Anna Barr	set Alexis Finnvold	+6.1
44	20-24	WVU	WVU×4	Attack err	Ava Siefke		+3.3
45	20-25	WVU	WVU×4	Attack err	Sophie Catalano		+2.3
Set 5
1	1-0	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+8.9
2	1-1	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Anna Barr	set Alexis Finnvold	+6.1
3	1-2	WVU	WVU	Kill	Nina Horning	set Alexis Finnvold	+9.3
4	2-2	WVU	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Janelle Green	+6.4
5	3-2	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Janelle Green	+9.6
6	4-2	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Meg Jarrett	+9.5
7	4-3	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Anna Barr	set Alexis Finnvold	+6.1
8	4-4	WVU	WVU	Ace	West Virginia		+9.9
9	5-4	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+7.2
10	5-5	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Lauren Duncan	+7.2
11	6-5	WVU	TOLEDO	Attack err	Trinity Sheridan		+7.6
12	6-6	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Reagan Turk	+7.6
13	7-6	WVU	TOLEDO×3	Serve err	West Virginia		+8.1
14	8-6	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Ava Siefke	set Grace Freiberger	+11.5
15	9-6	TOLEDO	TOLEDO×3	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+10.2
16	9-7	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Lauren Duncan	+5.5
17	10-7	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Kayla Ozanich	set Madelyn Bach	+7.3
18	10-8	TOLEDO	WVU	Serve err	Toledo		+5.5
19	11-8	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sierra Pertzborn	set Madelyn Bach	+7.6
20	11-9	TOLEDO	WVU	Blocked	Ava Siefke	blk Anna Barr, Camille Huff	+5.4
21	12-9	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+8.0
22	12-10	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Anna Barr	set Alexis Finnvold	+5.1
23	13-10	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+8.3
24	13-11	TOLEDO	WVU	Kill	Trinity Sheridan	set Lauren Duncan	+4.5
25	14-11	WVU	TOLEDO	Kill	Sophie Catalano	set Janelle Green	+8.3
26	15-11	TOLEDO	TOLEDO	Kill	Jessica Costlow	set Grace Freiberger	+4.4

Score shown after each rally, Toledo first. WP Δ = match win-probability points gained, colored by the team that gained them.“NCAA feed gap” rows mark points the NCAA play-by-play never logged (tap Why? for details).

Toledo def. West Virginia 3–2