Southern Ind. vs Evansville Volleyball: Evansville Wins 3-2

Final · 5 setsSat, Sep 19, 2026

2:3

Evansville beat visiting Southern Ind. 3-2 (25-18, 22-25, 19-25, 25-20, 15-13) on Sat, Sep 19, 2026. Ryan Scheu led Evansville with 15 kills; Southern Ind.'s Carley Wright had a match-high 16.

Data through Nov 3, 3:00 PM CT · final Sep 19

Set	1	2	3	4	5	Sets
S IND	18	25	25	20	13	2
EVANS	25	22	19	25	15	3

Win probability

Evansville above 50 · Southern Ind. below

Biggest swing: 32.3% to Evansville — set 5, S IND 13-15 EVANS. Mackenzie Nettles stuffed by Savannah Gogel & Carsyn Kelley. EVANS win probability 68% → 100%.

Pre-match

Season fit · includes this match

S IND 79.8%20.2% EVANS

Southern Ind. wins

3-0

31.4%

3-1

30.2%

3-2

18.3%

Evansville wins

3-0

3.3%

3-1

6.7%

3-2

10.2%

S IND break %: 46.2% vs this opp
EVANS break %: 39.8% vs this opp

Exact Markov model on each team's RallyIQ serve and receive strength, adjusted for schedule and applied to this matchup (D1 average break % 42.5%). Ratings use the whole season, including this match. Gold = actual result.

Top plays

Largest win-probability swings

01
Savannah Gogel&Carsyn KelleyBlock+32.3%
Mackenzie Nettles stuffed by Savannah Gogel & Carsyn Kelley
Set 5 · S IND 13-15 EVANS · EVANS 68% → 100%
02
Southern Ind.Service error+21.3%
Southern Ind. service error
Set 5 · S IND 13-14 EVANS · EVANS 46% → 68%
03
Southern Ind.Service error+16.8%
Southern Ind. service error
Set 5 · S IND 12-13 EVANS · EVANS 45% → 62%
04
Leah ColemanKill+15.4%
Kill by Leah Coleman (set by Aysa Thomas)
Set 5 · S IND 13-13 EVANS · S IND 38% → 54%
05
Lyla FisherKill+14.5%
Kill by Lyla Fisher (set by Carsyn Kelley)
Set 5 · S IND 9-10 EVANS · EVANS 39% → 53%
06
Southern Ind.Service error+14.1%
Southern Ind. service error
Set 5 · S IND 11-12 EVANS · EVANS 44% → 58%
07
Carley WrightKill+12.9%
Kill by Carley Wright (set by Aysa Thomas)
Set 5 · S IND 12-12 EVANS · S IND 42% → 55%
08
Ryan ScheuKill+12.3%
Kill by Ryan Scheu (set by Kendall Agler)
Set 5 · S IND 10-11 EVANS · EVANS 43% → 55%

Box score

Official NCAA box

Southern Ind.away

Player	S	K	E	TA	Hit%	AST	SA	SE	DIG	RE	BA	BLK	PTS
6Ashby WillisOH	5	15	11	60	.067	0	5	1	6	1	1	0.5	20.5
7Carley WrightOH	5	16	3	28	.464	1	1	4	17	2	3	1.5	18.5
2Aysa ThomasS	5	3	0	11	.273	39	0	1	11	0	2	1	4
17Aspen JankowskiS	5	0	0	0	–	0	4	1	2	0	0	0	4
4Kerigan FehrL/DS	5	1	0	1	1.000	1	1	2	9	3	0	0	2
10Vita SensenbrennerMB	4	2	3	9	-.111	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2
13Mackenzie NettlesOH	5	6	5	16	.063	1	0	0	0	0	6	3	9
5Audrey SmallL/DS	5	0	0	1	.000	4	4	1	15	0	0	0	4
22Leah ColemanOH	3	4	0	8	.500	1	0	0	4	0	1	0.5	4.5
3Aubrey FairOH	2	2	5	14	-.214	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2
20Jillian MoonanMB	2	2	3	9	-.111	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2
9Grace BachMB	2	0	0	0	–	0	0	0	0	0	1	0.5	0.5
Team totals		51	30	157	.134	47	15	10	64	6	14	7	101

Evansvillehome

Player	S	K	E	TA	Hit%	AST	SA	SE	DIG	RE	BS	BA	BLK	PTS
11Savannah GogelMB	5	14	3	29	.379	0	0	0	0	0	1	6	4	18
17Ryan ScheuOH	5	15	1	29	.483	1	0	0	5	0	0	1	0.5	15.5
3Wren JonesOH	5	13	5	40	.200	0	0	3	11	4	0	2	1	14
21McKenzie LaubachMB	5	8	1	17	.412	0	1	4	3	0	1	3	2.5	11.5
2Carsyn KelleyS	5	1	0	4	.250	49	0	2	8	0	0	5	2.5	3.5
7Lyla FisherOH	4	5	6	25	-.040	0	0	0	3	3	0	1	0.5	5.5
15Brooke HerdesOH	5	2	0	2	1.000	0	4	4	9	2	0	0	0	6
20Kendall AglerL/DS	5	0	0	0	–	4	1	4	20	2	0	0	0	1
6Lexi OwenS	5	0	0	0	–	2	0	1	11	3	0	0	0	0
13Holland MorrisOH	1	1	1	3	.000	0	0	0	1	0	0	0	0	1
10Aubry DowlingL/DS	1	0	0	0	–	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
Team totals		59	17	149	.282	56	6	18	71	15	2	18	11	106

Starters listed first. BLK is the NCAA total: a solo counts 1, a block assist ½. Recaps and press releases usually quote solos + assists instead, so the same night can be reported as a bigger, whole number. The box score is the source for every counting stat on this page.

Southern Ind. vs Evansville

Season series · Series tied 1-1

Fri, Sep 18, 2026Evansville at Southern Ind. · Southern Ind. won 3-0Result →
Sat, Sep 19, 2026Southern Ind. at Evansville · Evansville won 3-2This match

Momentum

Point differential by rally

Longest run 7 S IND · EVANS 6

Set 1

18-25

Longest run 3 S INDEVANS 4

Set 2

25-22

Longest run 7 S INDEVANS 4

Set 3

25-19

Longest run 5 S INDEVANS 6

Set 4

20-25

Longest run 5 S INDEVANS 6

Set 5

13-15

Longest run 3 S INDEVANS 3

Bars above the line = Evansville leads, below = Southern Ind. leads. Bright bars are points inside a run of 3+.

Rotations

Sideout and break % by rotation slot

Southern Ind.

Slot	Sideout %	Break %
1	59%10/17	30%3/10
2	48%10/21	29%4/14
3	67%10/15	64%18/28
4	59%10/17	38%6/16
5	47%9/19	29%4/14
6	35%6/17	58%11/19
All	52%55/106	46%46/101

Evansville

Slot	Sideout %	Break %
1	63%10/16	60%12/20
2	45%10/22	38%6/16
3	50%10/20	50%10/20
4	67%10/15	23%3/13
5	53%9/17	59%13/22
6	55%6/11	47%7/15
All	54%55/101	48%51/106

Slot = rotations since the start of the set (slot 1 is the lineup a team opened the set in), not a fixed player alignment. Only clean sets count (5 of 5 here): sets where the NCAA play-by-play has gaps or score corrections are left out because the rotation can't be tracked through them.

Rally log

207 rallies

#	S IND-EVANS	Srv	Point	End	Player	Setter / blockers / passer	WP Δ
Set 1
1	1-0	S IND	S IND	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Lyla Fisher	+1.6
2	2-0	S IND	S IND	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Lyla Fisher	+1.5
3	2-1	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Lyla Fisher	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.2
4	3-1	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.1
5	4-1	S IND	S IND	Attack err	Lyla Fisher		+1.4
6	4-2	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.0
7	4-3	EVANS	EVANS×3	Blocked	Vita Sensenbrenner	blk Savannah Gogel	+1.6
8	4-4	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.8
9	5-4	EVANS	S IND×3	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.3
10	6-4	S IND	S IND×3	Ace	Southern Ind.		+1.7
11	7-4	S IND	S IND×3	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Wren Jones	+1.5
12	7-5	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.1
13	7-6	EVANS	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Lexi Owen	+1.7
14	8-6	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+1.3
15	8-7	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.4
16	8-8	EVANS	EVANS×3	Attack err	Aubrey Fair		+2.1
17	8-9	EVANS	EVANS×3	Blocked	Mackenzie Nettles	blk McKenzie Laubach	+2.3
18	9-9	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Aubrey Fair	set Aysa Thomas	+1.6
19	9-10	S IND	EVANS	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Aysa Thomas	+1.8
20	10-10	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+1.7
21	10-11	S IND	EVANS	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+1.9
22	11-11	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+1.8
23	12-11	S IND	S IND	Attack err	Lyla Fisher		+2.3
24	12-12	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.8
25	12-13	EVANS	EVANS	Blocked	Vita Sensenbrenner	blk Savannah Gogel, Ryan Scheu	+2.7
26	13-13	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+1.9
27	13-14	S IND	EVANS×4	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Kendall Agler	+2.2
28	13-15	EVANS	EVANS×4	Blocked	Ashby Willis	blk Carsyn Kelley, Savannah Gogel	+3.0
29	13-16	EVANS	EVANS×4	Blocked	Jillian Moonan	blk Savannah Gogel, Lyla Fisher	+3.1
30	13-17	EVANS	EVANS×4	Attack err	Jillian Moonan		+2.9
31	14-17	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Vita Sensenbrenner	set Aysa Thomas	+1.6
32	15-17	S IND	S IND	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Wren Jones	+2.6
33	15-18	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.6
34	16-18	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Vita Sensenbrenner	set Aysa Thomas	+2.0
35	16-19	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.7
36	16-20	EVANS	EVANS	Blocked	Aubrey Fair	blk Carsyn Kelley, McKenzie Laubach	+3.1
37	17-20	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Mackenzie Nettles	set Aysa Thomas	+1.5
38	17-21	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Wren Jones	set Kendall Agler	+2.4
39	17-22	EVANS	EVANS×3	Attack err	Mackenzie Nettles		+2.2
40	17-23	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.2
41	18-23	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Aubrey Fair	set Aysa Thomas	+0.3
42	18-24	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.7
43	18-25	EVANS	EVANS	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+0.2
Set 2
1	1-0	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.8
2	1-1	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.0
3	2-1	EVANS	S IND×7	Kill	Jillian Moonan	set Audrey Small	+1.9
4	3-1	S IND	S IND×7	Attack err	Lyla Fisher		+2.4
5	4-1	S IND	S IND×7	Attack err	Lyla Fisher		+2.1
6	5-1	S IND	S IND×7	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Lexi Owen	+1.8
7	6-1	S IND	S IND×7	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Lexi Owen	+1.5
8	7-1	S IND	S IND×7	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Lexi Owen	+1.3
9	8-1	S IND	S IND×7	Attack err	Savannah Gogel		+1.0
10	8-2	S IND	EVANS×4	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.6
11	8-3	EVANS	EVANS×4	Blocked	Aubrey Fair	blk Carsyn Kelley, Savannah Gogel	+1.1
12	8-4	EVANS	EVANS×4	Attack err	Mackenzie Nettles		+1.4
13	8-5	EVANS	EVANS×4	Blocked	Jillian Moonan	blk Savannah Gogel, Wren Jones	+1.8
14	9-5	EVANS	S IND×3	Serve err	Evansville		+1.5
15	10-5	S IND	S IND×3	Kill	Aysa Thomas	set Savannah Gogel	+1.6
16	11-5	S IND	S IND×3	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Kendall Agler	+1.3
17	11-6	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+0.8
18	12-6	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+1.0
19	12-7	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.8
20	12-8	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.4
21	12-9	EVANS	EVANS×3	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+1.9
22	13-9	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Kerigan Fehr		+1.6
23	14-9	S IND	S IND	Attack err	Ryan Scheu		+1.7
24	14-10	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.1
25	14-11	EVANS	EVANS	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+2.0
26	15-11	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.7
27	15-12	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.5
28	15-13	EVANS	EVANS×3	Ace	Evansville	aced Kerigan Fehr	+2.7
29	15-14	EVANS	EVANS×3	Attack err	Vita Sensenbrenner		+3.4
30	16-14	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+2.7
31	16-15	S IND	EVANS×3	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+2.7
32	16-16	EVANS	EVANS×3	Attack err	Aubrey Fair		+4.4
33	16-17	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+5.1
34	17-17	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Jillian Moonan	set Aysa Thomas	+3.6
35	17-18	S IND	EVANS	Attack err	Aubrey Fair		+4.2
36	18-18	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Aysa Thomas		+3.9
37	18-19	S IND	EVANS	Attack err	Mackenzie Nettles		+4.5
38	18-20	EVANS	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Lexi Owen	+6.3
39	19-20	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+3.9
40	19-21	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+5.3
41	20-21	EVANS	S IND×5	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+4.2
42	21-21	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+6.8
43	22-21	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Kerigan Fehr	+7.3
44	23-21	S IND	S IND×5	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Brooke Herdes	+6.5
45	24-21	S IND	S IND×5	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Brooke Herdes	+4.2
46	24-22	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+1.3
47	25-22	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+2.8
Set 3
1	0-1	S IND	EVANS	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.1
2	1-1	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+2.0
3	1-2	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Lyla Fisher	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.2
4	1-3	EVANS	EVANS	Kill	Lyla Fisher	set Carsyn Kelley	+3.1
5	2-3	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+2.1
6	2-4	S IND	EVANS	Attack err	Carley Wright		+2.4
7	3-4	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+2.2
8	4-4	S IND	S IND	Kill	Leah Coleman	set Aysa Thomas	+2.9
9	4-5	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.4
10	5-5	EVANS	S IND×3	Serve err	Evansville		+2.2
11	6-5	S IND	S IND×3	Blocked	Wren Jones	blk Aysa Thomas, Mackenzie Nettles	+2.9
12	7-5	S IND	S IND×3	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+2.6
13	7-6	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+2.0
14	8-6	EVANS	S IND×5	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+2.0
15	9-6	S IND	S IND×5	Attack err	Wren Jones		+2.4
16	10-6	S IND	S IND×5	Blocked	McKenzie Laubach	blk Mackenzie Nettles, Ashby Willis	+2.1
17	11-6	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.7
18	12-6	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Mackenzie Nettles	set Aysa Thomas	+1.3
19	12-7	S IND	EVANS×6	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.8
20	12-8	EVANS	EVANS×6	Kill	Lyla Fisher	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.4
21	12-9	EVANS	EVANS×6	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+1.9
22	12-10	EVANS	EVANS×6	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.5
23	12-11	EVANS	EVANS×6	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Kendall Agler	+3.1
24	12-12	EVANS	EVANS×6	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+3.6
25	13-12	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Mackenzie Nettles	set Aysa Thomas	+2.7
26	13-13	S IND	EVANS	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.9
27	14-13	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+2.9
28	14-14	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+3.0
29	15-14	EVANS	S IND×5	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+3.0
30	16-14	S IND	S IND×5	Attack err	Lyla Fisher		+3.7
31	17-14	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+3.2
32	18-14	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Carley Wright	set Audrey Small	+2.5
33	19-14	S IND	S IND×5	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Lyla Fisher	+1.8
34	19-15	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Brooke Herdes	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.9
35	20-15	EVANS	S IND×3	Attack err	Savannah Gogel		+1.3
36	21-15	S IND	S IND×3	Blocked	Wren Jones	blk Carley Wright, Mackenzie Nettles	+1.0
37	22-15	S IND	S IND×3	Blocked	Savannah Gogel	blk Mackenzie Nettles, Leah Coleman	+0.5
38	22-16	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.2
39	22-17	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.4
40	22-18	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.8
41	23-18	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+1.0
42	23-19	S IND	EVANS	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.4
43	24-19	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+0.8
44	25-19	S IND	S IND	Blocked	Wren Jones	blk Aysa Thomas, Mackenzie Nettles	+0.2
Set 4
1	0-1	EVANS	EVANS	Kill	Carsyn Kelley	set Ryan Scheu	+2.2
2	1-1	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Audrey Small	+1.6
3	1-2	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.8
4	1-3	EVANS	EVANS	Attack err	Carley Wright		+2.5
5	2-3	EVANS	S IND×5	Serve err	Evansville		+1.7
6	3-3	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Mackenzie Nettles		+2.3
7	4-3	S IND	S IND×5	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Kendall Agler	+2.2
8	5-3	S IND	S IND×5	Kill	Aysa Thomas	set Mackenzie Nettles	+2.0
9	6-3	S IND	S IND×5	Blocked	Holland Morris	blk Carley Wright, Mackenzie Nettles	+1.8
10	6-4	S IND	EVANS	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+1.3
11	6-5	EVANS	EVANS	Bad set	Aysa Thomas		+2.1
12	7-5	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Leah Coleman	set Aysa Thomas	+1.6
13	7-6	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.6
14	8-6	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Mackenzie Nettles	set Aysa Thomas	+1.6
15	8-7	S IND	EVANS×6	Kill	Holland Morris	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.7
16	8-8	EVANS	EVANS×6	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.5
17	8-9	EVANS	EVANS×6	Ace	Evansville	aced Carley Wright	+2.8
18	8-10	EVANS	EVANS×6	Ace	Evansville	aced Kerigan Fehr	+3.0
19	8-11	EVANS	EVANS×6	Ace	Evansville	aced Carley Wright	+3.1
20	8-12	EVANS	EVANS×6	Ace	Evansville	aced Kerigan Fehr	+3.1
21	9-12	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+1.9
22	9-13	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.4
23	9-14	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Carsyn Kelley	+2.9
24	9-15	EVANS	EVANS×3	Blocked	Ashby Willis	blk Carsyn Kelley, McKenzie Laubach	+2.5
25	10-15	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+1.3
26	10-16	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Brooke Herdes	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.9
27	10-17	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	McKenzie Laubach	set Brooke Herdes	+1.9
28	10-18	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.4
29	11-18	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Audrey Small	+0.6
30	12-18	S IND	S IND	Attack err	Wren Jones		+1.1
31	12-19	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.3
32	13-19	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+0.7
33	13-20	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+1.2
34	14-20	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+0.6
35	15-20	S IND	S IND	Kill	Leah Coleman	set Aysa Thomas	+1.2
36	15-21	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+1.6
37	16-21	EVANS	S IND×3	Serve err	Evansville		+0.8
38	17-21	S IND	S IND×3	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.6
39	18-21	S IND	S IND×3	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Wren Jones	+2.4
40	18-22	S IND	EVANS	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+2.9
41	19-22	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Aysa Thomas	+1.6
42	20-22	S IND	S IND	Kill	Ashby Willis	set Carley Wright	+3.3
43	20-23	S IND	EVANS×3	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+4.1
44	20-24	EVANS	EVANS×3	Ace	Evansville	aced Ashby Willis	+3.4
45	20-25	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+0.1
Set 5
1	1-0	EVANS	S IND×3	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+5.6
2	2-0	S IND	S IND×3	Ace	Southern Ind.	aced Wren Jones	+7.0
3	3-0	S IND	S IND×3	Blocked	Lyla Fisher	blk Carley Wright, Grace Bach	+6.1
4	3-1	S IND	EVANS×3	Attack err	Ashby Willis		+4.4
5	3-2	EVANS	EVANS×3	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+7.1
6	3-3	EVANS	EVANS×3	Blocked	Carley Wright	blk McKenzie Laubach, Wren Jones	+8.5
7	4-3	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+6.4
8	5-3	S IND	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+8.0
9	5-4	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+5.9
10	6-4	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+6.2
11	6-5	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Carsyn Kelley	+6.1
12	6-6	EVANS	EVANS	Kill	Wren Jones	set Carsyn Kelley	+9.9
13	7-6	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Mackenzie Nettles	set Leah Coleman	+7.6
14	7-7	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+8.0
15	8-7	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+8.1
16	8-8	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Savannah Gogel	set Carsyn Kelley	+8.6
17	9-8	EVANS	S IND	Serve err	Evansville		+8.7
18	9-9	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+9.2
19	9-10	EVANS	EVANS	Kill	Lyla Fisher	set Carsyn Kelley	+14.5
20	10-10	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+10.2
21	10-11	S IND	EVANS	Kill	Ryan Scheu	set Kendall Agler	+12.3
22	11-11	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+11.4
23	11-12	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+14.1
24	12-12	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Carley Wright	set Aysa Thomas	+12.9
25	12-13	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+16.8
26	13-13	EVANS	S IND	Kill	Leah Coleman	set Aysa Thomas	+15.4
27	13-14	S IND	EVANS	Serve err	Southern Ind.		+21.3
28	13-15	EVANS	EVANS	Blocked	Mackenzie Nettles	blk Savannah Gogel, Carsyn Kelley	+32.3

Score shown after each rally, Southern Ind. first. WP Δ = match win-probability points gained, colored by the team that gained them.“NCAA feed gap” rows mark points the NCAA play-by-play never logged (tap Why? for details).

Evansville def. Southern Ind. 3–2